For the sake of this post, we’ll again narrow down the
spectrum to one of GMI’s brand sites – naturevalley.com – and analyze from that
perspective.
AV outlines nine steps in his blog post (located at http://www.kaushik.net/avinash/web-analytics-technical-implementation-best-practices-javascript-tags/).
Some of which I can tell GMI follows (from the web source code), and others
which aren’t so easy to evaluate without deeper access.
1.) Tag
all your pages
a.
GMI does seem to have all of the pages on
naturevalley.com JS tagged. I’m not technically sure if I’m allowed to copy and
paste the source into the blog, so just to be safe, I’ll let you view the code
for yourselves – which can be done easily in any web browser.
2.) Tags
go last
a.
All of the tags appear to be placed before the
closing header tag, so I’m going to assume these are async JS tags, otherwise I
imagine they would be before the closing body tag.
3.) Tags are inline
a.
I didn't see any odd placement of tags on
naturevalley.com – all of the tags were inline.
4.) Unique
page definition
a.
This isn’t so easy to discern, as the site is
uses Flash for the product page. Each product appears to have its own unique
subpage embedded within the larger encompassing product page.
5.) First
party cookies
a.
I honestly can’t say whether or not we use third
or first party cookies, since we don't sell product through the site, and we
don't have a sort of “account login” like we do on BettyCrocker.com – I’ll ask
someone and find out, though! J
6.) JS
Wrapped Links
a.
I didn't see anything like this in the code I
looked at.
7.) Redirects
a.
There are several of these throughout the site,
especially the homepage – where redirects to other brand and corporate sites
are placed.
8.) Validate
a.
I’m sure that there are several people our web team
whose sole task is to ensure that the data we need is being captured correctly,
however, that is beyond my purview.
9.) Rich
Media (i.e. Flash, RSS, etc.)
a.
naturevalley.com uses a ton of rich media across
the site, so I imagine our tracking of the site increases in complexity – as AV
suggests.
From the looks of what I can see, I would say that GMI is doing everything they need to ensure that their sites are being measured in a meaningful way. The JS tags are placed properly and used carefully, and the site is clean, quick to load, and easy to navigate.
Nice analysis. For your own knowledge, you may ask them how they're tracking their rich media portions of the site (if they'll share) -- those parts can be very tricky.
ReplyDeleteHmm. I'll have to ask and see. Thanks!
Delete